As countries on all continents start taking steps towards relaxing lockdown measures, governments are grappling with how to maintain the spread of the virus at manageable levels as people are once again allowed to leave their homes. As a result, most countries who had not already rolled out some version of a tracing app to their populations are now planning to do so. Governments must take great care to preserve human rights in doing so.
While tracing apps will by no means solve the problem on their own, countries like Taiwan and South Korea have shown that they can be effective when used as a complement to other virus tracing measures. However, depending on the model chosen, such apps may carry large amounts of sensitive data. For example, the app could store information related to the location and health of the user. This poses a range of risks to privacy.
In South Korea, location information about COVID-positive users has been made public and caused rumours and public shaming. In China, a country not exactly known for its respect for citizens’ privacy, people are given different colour codes depending on their status. These colour codes determine to what extent they are allowed to participate in society.
In Europe, discussions have centred around Bluetooth-based apps that do not collect data in a centralised manner. In such decentralised systems, information is less vulnerable and it is more difficult for governments to use a centralised pool of data for other purposes than directly fighting the virus. However, the lack of centrality also makes the information inaccessible to public authorities to establish a broader picture of the virus spread in society.
Some countries, like Sweden, have concluded that the threats to privacy and individual rights are too great, and have chosen to abandon the idea of a tracing app entirely.
The respect of governments for their citizens’ right to privacy is essential for any such system to work effectively. When trust and a sense of legitimacy is built between citizens and authorities, and citizens rely on their governments to use their data fairly and transparently, citizens are more likely to provide accurate information. In badly designed systems without trust, citizens will instead try to avoid providing the authorities with information.
As the Liberal International Human Rights Committee has previously called for, it is essential that the coronavirus is not used as an excuse to impose mass surveillance. The implementation of tracing apps may be a key tool to fighting the virus – but it may also be a step towards ubiquitous government surveillance. It is crucial that governments carefully consider the human rights implications of their chosen path and take citizens’ privacy and concerns seriously.
Main image: Blogtrepreneur via Flickr